10 Tips for Building a Setlist That Keeps People Watching

As a musician, your setlist is the ultimate tool in engaging your audience and creating a memorable performance. It’s not just about the music, but the way you curate the experience for your fans. The right setlist keeps people on their feet, wanting more, and ensures that they’ll remember the show long after it ends. Here are 10 tips to help you craft a setlist that will keep the energy high and your audience glued to the stage.

Start Strong with a Bang
You only get one chance to make a first impression, so why not start your set with a song that hits hard? Whether it’s a crowd favorite or a high-energy track, your opener should immediately grab attention and set the tone for the rest of the show. The right opener can get people excited and signal that they’re in for a ride.

Pace Yourself
Building momentum is key. You don’t want to blow all your best songs right out of the gate. Mix in your high-energy songs with slower, more emotional moments. This gives the audience a chance to catch their breath and keeps them engaged without overwhelming them. Finding the right ebb and flow keeps people intrigued and emotionally invested.

Consider Your Audience
While your setlist should reflect your personal style and creative choices, it’s important to think about your audience. If you’re playing for a crowd that’s familiar with your hits, pepper in the well-loved songs. For a more casual crowd, you might want to ease them in with some of your more accessible material before diving into the deep cuts. Tailor the setlist to keep people engaged from start to finish.

Highlight Your Band’s Strengths
Every band has strengths, whether it’s the tightness of your rhythm section or the virtuosity of your lead guitarist. Make sure your setlist reflects these strengths. Showcase your band’s musicality in a way that feels natural and allows each member to shine. A strong instrumental moment or a vocal harmony breakdown can captivate your audience and give everyone a chance to appreciate the talent on stage.

Create a Narrative Arc
A well-curated setlist isn’t just a random collection of songs; it tells a story. Think of your set like an emotional journey, starting with excitement, dipping into quieter moments, building again, and finishing on a high note. Your audience will appreciate the ebb and flow, and they’ll remember the arc of the night as a cohesive experience rather than just a string of songs.

Don’t Overstay Your Welcome
The best shows leave the audience wanting more, not wishing they could check their watches. Be mindful of your set’s length—anything over 90 minutes might start to feel like too much, especially if the energy starts to dip. Don’t be afraid to cut a song if the vibe is off or if you feel like your audience is ready for the finale. Keep it tight and impactful.

Use Covers Wisely
A great cover can inject fresh energy into your set, but be careful not to rely on them too heavily. When choosing a cover, make sure it aligns with your style and fits seamlessly into your set. Whether it’s a personal twist on a classic or a fun tribute to an artist you admire, a cover can be a great way to mix things up without losing the flow of your performance.

Incorporate Some Surprises
Keep the crowd on their toes with a few surprises along the way. This could be an unexpected cover, a brand-new song, or even a stripped-back acoustic moment that shows a different side of your music. Surprises make your show unique, and it gives your audience something to remember. Just be sure that any surprises feel natural and don’t disrupt the overall vibe.

Give the Crowd a Chance to Sing Along
Your audience wants to be part of the experience. Don’t forget to include moments in your set where the crowd can sing along. Whether it’s a catchy chorus or a timeless anthem, involving your audience in the music creates a communal experience that will resonate long after the show ends.

End on a High Note
The last song of your set is your chance to leave a lasting impression. Choose something that brings the energy back up, something that gets the crowd cheering. This could be one of your biggest hits, a fan favorite, or an emotionally charged anthem. A powerful ending ensures that your audience will walk away feeling like they’ve experienced something unforgettable.