John Darnielle and Matt Douglas walked into Sony Hall in November without a rehearsal and delivered one of the more memorable sets of the year. That kind of confidence only comes from two things: deep trust in the material and a genuine comfort with the unexpected. The Mountain Goats have both in abundance.
The stripped-back duo show, part of “An Evening with The Mountain Goats and Molly Tuttle,” served as a WFUV benefit at Sony Hall. The timing aligned with the release of a new Mountain Goats album, ‘Through This Fire Across from Peter Balkan’, a title Darnielle says arrived in a dream. Two tracks from the record made the set, including “Rocks in the Pockets,” played live only for the third time, and “Broken to Begin With.”
Douglas moved fluidly between electric guitar, tenor sax, piano, and keyboards across the evening, while Darnielle held the room with stream-of-consciousness intros that zigzagged from rural Iowa to Merle Haggard to Waylon Jennings to Ozzy Osbourne without ever losing the thread. His candid, sombre reflection on his complicated relationship with his late stepfather gave the set real emotional ballast, landing just before “Southwestern Territory.”
The set closed with “No Children” from 2002’s ‘Tallahassee’, Darnielle yelping the final line with full commitment. It was a fitting exit.