Tom Scholz recorded one of the best-selling debut albums in rock history in a flooded basement next to a furnace, on equipment he built himself, while lying to a major record label about where he was doing it. Epic Records thought the album was being made in Los Angeles. It was being made in Watertown, Massachusetts, in a tiny pine-panelled room that Scholz described as “hideous.” The label had signed what they suspected might be “a mad genius at work in a basement.” They were right. ‘Boston’ was released in August 1976, has sold at least 17 million copies in the United States alone, and remains one of the greatest corporate capers in the history of the music business. Here are five things you probably didn’t know about it.
Epic Records Had Already Rejected the Band — With an Insulting Letter
Before ‘Boston’ became the fastest-selling debut album in American rock history, Epic Records passed on it flat. The rejection letter, signed by company head Lennie Petze, opined that the band “offered nothing new.” RCA, Capitol, Atlantic, and Elektra had all turned them down too. The tape that eventually landed at Epic only got there because a Polaroid co-worker of Scholz’s forgot to mail it to ABC Records and left it sitting on his desk for months — where someone else overheard it, called a promoter in California, who called Petze back. The man who wrote the insulting letter ended up signing the band.
The Bulk of the Album Was Recorded With a $100 Guitar
While producer John Boylan arranged for singer Brad Delp to have a custom Taylor acoustic guitar charged to the album budget for thousands of dollars, Scholz was back in Watertown quietly recording “More Than a Feeling” on a $100 Yamaha acoustic he had bought himself. Boylan’s role was essentially to take the rest of the band to Los Angeles as a decoy — keeping Epic happy while Scholz did the actual work at home. The label never knew. “What they didn’t know wouldn’t hurt them,” Delp later said. When Scholz finally handed over a complete tape, the label thought the band had worked extraordinarily fast.
“Foreplay” — the Opening of the Album’s Most Epic Track — Was Written in 1969
“Foreplay/Long Time” is nearly eight minutes long and sounds like the kind of track that takes years to construct. It did. Scholz has said that “Foreplay” was not only the first song he ever recorded, but the first piece of music he ever wrote — composed as far back as 1969, a full seven years before it appeared on the album. He recorded the original version on a two-track machine in his basement. By the time it showed up on ‘Boston’, it had been sitting in Scholz’s head for most of a decade, waiting for the rest of the world to catch up.
Nirvana Quoted “More Than a Feeling” at Reading — and Nobody Missed the Point
When Kurt Cobain took the stage at the 1992 Reading Festival, he opened Nirvana’s set by playing the opening riff of “More Than a Feeling” — a deliberate nod to what many critics had already noticed: that “Smells Like Teen Spirit” shares a chord progression with it. Scholz had always credited “Walk Away Renée” by The Left Banke as the song’s main inspiration, and the guitar progression that follows the line “I see my Marianne walking away” is directly borrowed from that track. So the lineage runs from a 1966 baroque pop song to a 1976 arena rock anthem to a 1991 grunge landmark. Not bad for a tune written in a flooded Massachusetts basement.
They Lost the Grammy for Best New Artist to a One-Hit Wonder — and Then Sold 17 Million Albums
Boston were nominated for the Grammy Award for Best New Artist for their debut album, which by any measure should have been a lock. They lost to the Starland Vocal Band, whose surprise hit “Afternoon Delight” had caught the mood of America’s Bicentennial summer. The Starland Vocal Band never had another significant hit. Boston went on to sell 17 million copies of their debut in the United States alone, went Diamond, and placed every single song on the album into permanent classic rock radio rotation. The Grammy voters have had fifty years to think about that one.

