The Off-Broadway revival of “Little Shop of Horrors” has a new leading trio, and it’s a strong one. Jordan Fisher takes over as Seymour, Nikki M. James steps in as Audrey, and Andy Karl joins the company as the gloriously unhinged Dr. Orin Scrivello, D.D.S. The production continues its run at the Westside Theatre in New York, and this cast shake-up gives audiences every reason to go back.
Fisher and James are already in place, with Karl having joined the company March 10. Their predecessors, Joshua Bassett and Joy Woods, wrapped their respective runs after earning genuine praise for their portrayals of Seymour and Audrey.
Producer Tom Kirdahy spoke warmly about the outgoing cast: “Joshua and Joy have brought such sincerity, joy, and soul to Seymour and Audrey. Their performances have been a true gift to this production, and we are deeply grateful for the magic they’ve shared with our company and audiences.”
This revival has made a habit of landing remarkable performers in its lead roles. Past Seymours and Audreys include Jonathan Groff, Jeremy Jordan, Darren Criss, Evan Rachel Wood, Constance Wu, Sarah Hyland, and Corbin Bleu, among others. Jinkx Monsoon also made history during the run as the first drag queen to portray Audrey in a major production of the musical.
Directed by Michael Mayer with choreography by Ellenore Scott, the production is tight, wickedly funny, and built around some of musical theatre’s most enduring songs. With Fisher, James, and Karl now leading the company, “Little Shop of Horrors” remains one of the sharpest tickets Off-Broadway has going. Grab yours at littleshopnyc.com.